基于综合指标法的国土空间总体规划气候风险评 估方法研究
Research on Climate Risk Assessment Method for National Territorial Spatial Planning Based on Comprehensive Index Method
钱 昊
上海市城市规划设计研究院 高级工程师,经济师,硕士 448538467@qq.com 上海市量子城市空间智能创新重点实验室(筹) 规划分中心 成员
姜紫莹
上海市城市规划设计研究院 高级工程师,硕士
李梦芸
上海市城市规划设计研究院 工程师,硕士
刘 龙
上海市城市规划设计研究院 高级工程师,硕士
时 寅
上海市城市规划设计研究院 工程师,硕士
田田甜
上海市城市规划设计研究院 助理工程师,博士
摘要: 当前气候变化已经成为最受关注的议题之一。为了在国土空间总体规划中纳入适应气候变化的内容,需要通过气候风 险评估开展基础分析。既有的风险评估方法中综合指标法是一种简便实用且应用广泛的方法,但其应用中也存在混合 气候变化的不同影响、指标设定一致性不足等问题。通过优化综合指标法的评估框架,提出了分地区类型、分风险影响 类型的气候风险评估技术方法,使其更加适应国土空间总体规划的需求,并以上海市中心城作为案例区域,对方法的 具体应用情况进行了阐释说明。
Abstract: Climate change has become one of the most pressing issues. In order to incorporate climate change adaptation into territorial spatial master planning, it is necessary to conduct basic analysis through climate risk assessment. Among existing risk assessment methods, the comprehensive index method is a logically clear and widely used method. However, there are problems such as excessive evaluation elements and lack of specificity in its application. By optimizing the framework of this method, this paper proposes a technical approach that differentiates by region type and risk impact category, which is designed to better align with the requirements of territorial spatial master planning. The specific application process of the method is explained in detail using the central city of Shanghai as a case study.
关键词:气候风险评估;综合指标法;国土空间总体规划;上海
Keyword: climate risk assessment; comprehensive index method; territorial spatial master planning; Shanghai
中图分类号:TU984
文献标识码: A
周波涛,钱进. IPCC AR6报告解读:极端天气气
候事件变化[J]. 气候变化研究进展,2021,17
(6):713-718.
ZHOU Botao, QIAN Jin. Interpretation of the
IPCC AR6 Report: changes in extreme weather
and climate events[J]. Advances in Climate Change
Research, 2021, 17(6): 713-718.
胡婷,孙颖. IPCC AR6报告解读:人类活动对气
候系统的影响[J]. 气候变化研究进展,2021,
17(6):644-651.
HU Ting, SUN Ying. Interpretation of the IPCC
AR6 Report: impact of human activities on the
climate system[J]. Advances in Climate Change
Research, 2021, 17(6): 644-651.
周天军,陈梓明,陈晓龙,等. IPCC AR6报告解
读:未来的全球气候——基于情景的预估和近
期信息[J]. 气候变化研究进展,2021,17(6):
652-663.
ZHOU Tianjun, CHEN Ziming, CHEN Xiaolong,
et al. Interpretation of the IPCC AR6 Report:
future global climate—scenario-based projections
and near-term information[J]. Advances in Climate
Change Research, 2021, 17(6): 652-663.
中华人民共和国生态环境部等. 国家适应气候变
化战略2035[Z]. 2022.
Ministry of Ecology and Environment of the People’s
Republic of China, et al. National strategy for climate
change adaptation 2035[Z]. 2022.
中华人民共和国自然资源部. 市级国土空间总
体规划编制指南(试行)[Z]. 2020.
Ministry of Natural Resources of the People’s
Republic of China. Guidelines for the compilation
of municipal territorial spatial master plans (trial)
[Z]. 2020.
王蕾,张百超,石英,等. IPCC AR6报告关于气候
变化影响和风险主要结论的解读[J]. 气候变化
研究进展,2022,18(4):389-394.
WANG Lei, ZHANG Baichao, SHI Ying, et al.
Interpretation of the main conclusions on climate
change impacts and risks in the IPCC AR6 Report[J].
Advances in Climate Change Research, 2022,
18(4): 389-394.
吴绍洪,高江波,邓浩宇,等. 气候变化风险及其
定量评估方法[J]. 地理科学进展,2018,37(1):
28-35.
WU Shaohong, GAO Jiangbo, DENG Haoyu,
et al. Climate change risks and their quantitative
assessment methods[J]. Progress in Geography,
2018, 37(1): 28-35.
彭鹏,张韧,洪梅,等. 气候变化影响与风险评估
方法的研究进展[J]. 大气科学学报,2015,38
(2):155-164.
PENG Peng, ZHANG Ren, HONG Mei, et al.
Research progress on climate change impact
and risk assessment methods[J]. Transactions of
Atmospheric Sciences, 2015, 38(2): 155-164.
史培军. 三论灾害研究的理论与实践[J]. 自然灾
害学报,2002(3):1-9.
SHI Peijun. Third discussion on the theory and
practice of disaster research[J]. Journal of Natural
Disasters, 2002(3): 1-9.
史培军. 再论灾害研究的理论与实践[J]. 自然灾
害学报,1996(4):8-19.
SHI Peijun. Re-discussion on the theory and
practice of disaster research[J]. Journal of Natural
Disasters, 1996(4): 8-19.
周姝天,翟国方,施益军,等. 城市自然灾害风险评
估研究综述[J]. 灾害学,2020,35(4):180-186.
ZHOU Shutian, ZHAI Guofang, SHI Yijun, et al.
A review of urban natural disaster risk assessment
research[J]. Journal of Catastrophology, 2020,
35(4): 180-186.
武夕琳,刘庆生,刘高焕,等. 高温热浪风险评估
研究综述[J]. 地球信息科学学报,2019,21(7):
1029-1039.
WU Xilin, LIU Qingsheng, LIU Gaohuan, et al. A
review of heat wave risk assessment research[J].
Journal of Geo-Information Science, 2019, 21(7):
1029-1039.
王丹舟,张强,朱秀迪,等. 基于多源数据的上海
市高温热浪风险评估[J]. 北京师范大学学报(自
然科学版),2021,57(5):613-623.
WANG Danzhou, ZHANG Qiang, ZHU Xiudi, et
al. Heat wave risk assessment in Shanghai based
on multi-source data[J]. Journal of Beijing Normal
University (Natural Science Edition), 2021, 57(5):
613-623.
李国一,刘家宏,邵薇薇. 洪涝灾害风险评估与
分区研究进展[J]. 水文,2023,43(4):15-20.
LI Guoyi, LIU Jiahong, SHAO Weiwei. Research
progress on flood disaster risk assessment and
zoning[J]. Journal of Hydrology, 2023, 43(4): 15-20.
温旭敏,张鹏,戴尔阜. 中国市级尺度的高温风险
评估(英文)[J]. 资源与生态学报,2023,14(2):
399-409.
WEN Xumin, ZHANG Peng, DAI Erfu. Hightemperature risk assessment at the municipal scale
in China (in English)[J]. Journal of Resources and
Ecology, 2023, 14(2): 399-409.
何苗,徐永明,莫亚萍,等. 基于多源遥感数据的
北京市高温热浪风险综合评估[J]. 地理科学,
2023,43(7):1270-1280.
HE Miao, XU Yongming, MO Yaping, et al.
Comprehensive assessment of heat wave risk in
Beijing based on multi-source remote sensing
data[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2023, 43(7):
1270-1280.
张思超,吴凌云,戴秋丹,等. 安徽阜阳夏季极端
高温趋势分析与风险评估[J]. 气候与环境研究,
2024,29(2):145-154.
ZHANG Sichao, WU Lingyun, DAI Qiudan, et
al. Trend analysis and risk assessment of extreme
summer high temperatures in Fuyang, Anhui[J].
Climatic and Environmental Research, 2024,
29(2): 145-154.
韩亚静,刘慧,任建成,等. 滨州市高温灾害风险
评估与区划[J]. 山东理工大学学报(自然科学
版),2024,38(6):19-26.
HAN Yajing, LIU Hui, REN Jiancheng, et al.
Risk assessment and zoning of high-temperature
disasters in Binzhou City[J]. Journal of Shandong
University of Technology (Natural Science
Edition), 2024, 38(6): 19-26.
王德运,冀承泽,张露丹,等. 城市洪涝风险的多
方法组合评估与应用[J]. 灾害学,2024,39(1):
96-103.
WANG Deyun, JI Chengze, ZHANG Ludan,
et al. Multi-method combined assessment and
application of urban flood risk[J]. Journal of
Catastrophology, 2024, 39(1): 96-103.
杨林川,杨皓森,范强雪,等. 大城市高温热浪脆
弱性评价及规划应对研究——以成都市为例[J].
规划师,2023,39(2):38-45.
YANG Linchuan, YANG Haosen, FAN Qiangxue,
et al. Vulnerability evaluation of heat waves in
megacities and planning responses—a case study
of Chengdu[J]. Planners, 2023, 39(2): 38-45.
黄海静,马金辉,杨雨飞. 山地城市高温热浪灾
害空间识别与风险评估——以重庆市为例[J].
风景园林,2024,31(8):95-103.
HUANG Haijing, MA Jinhui, YANG Yufei.
Spatial identification and risk assessment of heat
wave disasters in mountainous cities—a case study
of Chongqing[J]. Landscape Architecture, 2024,
31(8): 95-103.
王倩,潘蓉,郭崇文,等. 杭州市主城区暴雨内涝灾
害风险评估研究[J]. 安全,2024,45(2):32-39.
WANG Qian, PAN Rong, GUO Chongwen, et al.
Risk assessment of rainstorm waterlogging disasters
in the main urban area of Hangzhou[J]. Safety,
2024, 45(2): 32-39.
孙梦瑶,赵俊英,乔雅男. 基于AHP-CRITIC法城
市暴雨洪水灾害风险评估的研究[J/OL]. 天津理
工 大 学 学 报:1-9[2026-02-11]. https://link.cnki.
net/urlid/12.1374.N.20240514.1447.044.
SUN Mengyao, ZHAO Junying, QIAO Ya'nan.
Research on urban rainstorm flood disaster risk
assessment based on the AHP-CRITIC method[J/
OL]. Journal of Tianjin University of Technology:
1-9[2026-02-11]. https://link.cnki.net/urlid/12.1374.
N.20240514.1447.044.
罗紫元,田健,丁锶湲,等. 基于熵权TOPSIS和神
经网络复合方法的厦门市雨洪灾害风险评估[J].
灾害学,2022,37(4):184-192.
LUO Ziyuan, TIAN Jian, DING Siyuan, et al. Risk
assessment of rainstorm flood disasters in Xiamen
based on the combined method of entropyweighted TOPSIS and neural network[J]. Journal
of Catastrophology, 2022, 37(4): 184-192.
尹占娥. 城市自然灾害风险评估与实证研究[D].
上海:华东师范大学,2009.
YIN Zhan'e. Risk assessment and empirical
research on urban natural disasters[D]. Shanghai:
East China Normal University, 2009.
赵路伟. 重庆市高温灾害风险评价研究[D]. 重
庆:西南大学,2016.
ZHAO Luwei. Research on high-temperature disaster
risk evaluation in Chongqing[D]. Chongqing:
Southwest University, 2016.
熊凡. 基于GIS和RS的江西省洪涝灾害风险评估
研究[D]. 赣州:江西理工大学,2023.
XIONG Fan. Research on flood disaster risk
assessment in Jiangxi Province based on GIS and
RS[D]. Ganzhou: Jiangxi University of Science
and Technology, 2023.
顾盼盼,缑少伟. 郑州市高温热浪风险评估及其
空间特征分析[J]. 北京测绘,2023,37(4):
542-546.
GU Panpan, GOU Shaowei. Risk assessment and
spatial characteristic analysis of heat waves in
Zhengzhou[J]. Beijing Surveying and Mapping,
2023, 37(4): 542-546.
刘子龙,张晓昕,王强,等. 模型技术在雨水管网
规划设计中的应用研究[J]. 北京师范大学学报
(自然科学版),2024,60(5):651-658.
LIU Zilong, ZHANG Xiaoxin, WANG Qiang, et al.
Research on the application of model technology
in rainwater pipe network planning and design[J].
Journal of Beijing Normal University (Natural
Science Edition), 2024, 60(5): 651-658.
刘燕. 基于郑州特大暴雨后城市雨水系统设计的
建议[J]. 城市道桥与防洪,2022(12):139-142.
LIU Yan. Suggestions on urban rainwater system
design after the extraordinary heavy rain in
Zhengzhou[J]. Urban Roads, Bridges and Flood
Control, 2022(12): 139-142.
张辰,李春鞠,陈嫣. 《室外排水设计标准》(GB
50014-2021)十问十答[J]. 给水排水,2022,58
(1):13-18.
ZHANG Chen, LI Chunju, CHEN Yan. Ten
questions and answers on code for Design of Outdoor Drainage (GB 50014-2021)[J]. Water &
Wastewater Engineering, 2022, 58(1): 13-18.
王强,张晓昕,韦明杰,等. 北京市城市雨水排除
系统规划设计标准研究[J]. 给水排水,2011,
47(10):34-39.
WANG Qiang, ZHANG Xiaoxin, WEI Mingjie,
et al. Research on planning and design standards
for urban rainwater drainage systems in Beijing[J].
Water & Wastewater Engineering, 2011, 47(10):
34-39.
苑希民,兰卓青,王丽娜,等. 极端天气城市特大
暴雨洪涝灾害特征再分析及应对策略[J]. 水利
学报,2024,55(11):1298-1308.
YUAN Ximin, LAN Zhuoqing, WANG Li'na, et al.
Reanalysis of the characteristics of extraordinary
rainstorm and flood disasters in cities under
extreme weather and countermeasures[J]. Journal of
Hydraulic Engineering, 2024, 55(11): 1298-1308.
徐宝同,夏雨晴,张娜. 郑州“7•20”特大暴雨
重演条件下永定河泛区洪涝风险分析与应对措
施[J]. 河北水利,2024(6):29-31.
XU Baotong, XIA Yuqing, ZHANG Na. Flood risk
analysis and countermeasures in Yongding River
flood detention area under the reoccurrence of
Zhengzhou ‘7•20’ extraordinary heavy rainstorm[J].
Hebei Water Resources, 2024(6): 29-31.
左利兴,张豪,张增棨,等. 城市道路交通应对超
标降雨的策略——以郑州“7•20”特大暴雨为
例[J]. 城市交通,2024,22(5):57-65.
ZUO Lixing, ZHANG Hao, ZHANG Zengqi,
et al. Strategies for urban road traffic to respond
to exceedance standard rainfall—a case study
of Zhengzhou ‘7•20’ extraordinary heavy
rainstorm[J]. Urban Transport of China, 2024,
22(5): 57-65.
干靓,凌云,李健. 供需协调视角下城市应急救
援可达性评估——以郑州“7•20”特大暴雨为
例[J]. 城市交通,2024,22(5):50-56.
GAN Liang, LING Yun, LI Jian. Accessibility
assessment of urban emergency rescue from the
perspective of supply-demand coordination—a case
study of Zhengzhou ‘7•20’ extraordinary heavy
rainstorm[J]. Urban Transport of China, 2024,
22(5): 50-56.
蒋帅,张黎,景元书,等. 1981—2015年中国区域
极端气候事件的时空分布特征[J]. 水土保持研
究,2023,30(6):295-306.
JIANG Shuai, ZHANG Li, JING Yuanshu, et
al. Spatiotemporal distribution characteristics of
regional extreme climate events in China from 1981
to 2015[J]. Research of Soil and Water Conservation,
2023, 30(6): 295-306.
翟盘茂,刘静. 气候变暖背景下的极端天气气候
事件与防灾减灾[J]. 中国工程科学,2012,14
(9):55-63.
ZHAI Panmao, LIU Jing. Extreme weather and
climate events under global warming and disaster
prevention and mitigation[J]. Engineering Sciences,
2012, 14(9): 55-63.
张晓敏,刘知微,方寒,等. 基于Landsat 8 TIRS地
表温度数据反演的深圳城市热岛效应时空分布
及土地利用的影响[J]. 气候与环境研究,2023,
28(3):242-250.
ZHANG Xiaomin, LIU Zhiwei, FANG Han, et al.
Spatiotemporal distribution of urban heat island
effect in Shenzhen and the impact of land use
based on Landsat 8 TIRS land surface temperature
inversion[J]. Climatic and Environmental Research,
2023, 28(3): 242-250.
孙晓玲. 亚洲陆地生态系统及其对高温热浪暴
露度的未来变化预估研究[D]. 南京:南京信息
工程大学,2023.
SUN Xiaoling. Study on future changes in Asian
terrestrial ecosystems and their exposure to heat
waves[D]. Nanjing: Nanjing University of Information Science & Technology, 2023.
翟端强,卓健,张诗洁. 国土空间生态风险评估
的国际经验比较及启示[J]. 城市问题,2022(8):
90-98.
ZHAI Duanqiang, ZHUO Jian, ZHANG Shijie.
Comparison of international experiences and
enlightenments on territorial spatial ecological risk
assessment[J]. Urban Problems, 2022(8): 90-98.
李世奎,霍治国,王素艳,等. 农业气象灾害风险
评估体系及模型研究[J]. 自然灾害学报,2004
(1):77-87.
LI Shikui, HUO Zhiguo, WANG Suyan, et al.
Research on the risk assessment system and model
of agrometeorological disasters[J]. Journal of
Natural Disasters, 2004(1): 77-87.
王春乙,张继权,霍治国,等. 农业气象灾害风险
评估研究进展与展望[J]. 气象学报,2015,73
(1):1-19.
WANG Chunyi, ZHANG Jiquan, HUO Zhiguo, et
al. Research progress and prospect of agrometeorological disaster risk assessment[J]. Acta Meteorologica Sinica, 2015, 73(1): 1-19.