儿童的健康促进:城市多维影响效应研究的进展与启示
Health Promotion for Children: Research Progress on the Effects of Urban Multidimensional Influences and Its Enlightenments
冷 红
哈尔滨工业大学建筑与设计学院 自然资源部寒地国土空间规划与生态保护修复 重点实验室 博士,教授,博士生导师,hitlaura@126.com
赵佳琪
哈尔滨工业大学建筑与设计学院 自然资源部寒地国土空间规划与生态保护修复 重点实验室 博士研究生
袁 青
哈尔滨工业大学建筑与设计学院 自然资源部寒地国土空间规划与生态保护修复 重点实验室 博士,教授,博士生导师
摘要: 在健康城市和儿童友好城市深入建设的背景下,儿童健康问题备受关注,目前城市环境对儿童健康的促进作用已得到 大量研究证实。借助引文空间(CiteSpace)工具,将健康促进作为线索,对比国内外研究现状,梳理以儿童为中心的城 市研究。聚焦政策、行为、环境3个方面,总结城市多维影响下的儿童健康促进效应研究进展。在此基础上建构未来研究 的分析框架,以政策维度的“推动关注对象的普及化”,行为维度的“拓展学科视角的交叉化、促进技术方法的多元 化”,环境维度的“实现焦点目标的差异化、挖掘要素关系的精细化”为视角,提出面向未来研究的启示与展望。
Abstract: In the context of the intensive construction of healthy cities and child-friendly cities, children’s health has received increasing attention. Currently, the promoting effects of urban environments on children’s health have been confirmed by extensive research. Using CiteSpace, this paper takes health promotion as a starting point, compares the current status of domestic and international research, and sorts out child-centered urban studies. Focusing on policy, behavior, and environment, it summarizes the progress of research on children’s health promotion effects under multidimensional urban influences. On this basis, an analytical framework for future research is constructed. The paper provides enlightenments and perspectives from three dimensions: promoting the popularization of attention targets in the policy dimension, expanding interdisciplinary perspectives and diversifying technical methods in the behavioral dimension, and realizing the differentiation of research objectives and exploring the precision of elemental relationships in the environmental dimension.
关键词:健康促进;环境效应;儿童;分析框架
Keyword: health promotion; environmental effect; children; analytical framework
中图分类号:TU981
文献标识码: A
GILLESPIE J. Being and becoming: writing
children into planning theory[J]. Planning Theory,
2013, 12(1): 64-80.
联合国儿童基金会. 构建儿童友好型城市和社区
手册[EB/OL]. (2019-05-01)[2024-07-01]. https://
www.unicef.cn/reports/cfci-handbook.
UNICEF. Shaping urbanization for children: a
handbook on child-responsive urban planning[EB/
OL]. (2019-05-01) [2024-07-01]. https://www.
unicef.cn/reports/cfci-handbook.
Health and Welfare Canada. Ottawa charter for
health promotion[J]. Canadian Journal of Public
Health, 1986, 77: 425-426.
裴昱,党安荣. 城市社区尺度下空间对儿童健康
的作用机理研究进展[J]. 现代城市研究,2023
(5):1-7.
PEI Yu, DANG Anrong. Advances in the mechanism
of space on child health at the scale of urban community[J]. Modern Urban Research, 2023(5): 1-7.
何灏宇,谭俊杰,廖绮晶,等. 基于儿童友好的健
康社区营造策略研究[J]. 上海城市规划,2021
(1):8-15.
HE Haoyu, TAN Junjie, LIAO Qijing, et al. Research
on strategies for building healthy communities based
on child-friendly perspectives[J]. Shanghai Urban
Planning Review, 2021(1): 8-15.
POTESTIO M L, PATEL A B, POWELL C D, et
al. Is there an association between spatial access
to parks/green space and childhood overweight/
obesity in Calgary, Canada?[J]. International
Journal of Behavioral Nutrition and Physical
Activity, 2009(6): 77.
SHAO L, HE X, TANG Y, et al. Outdoor cold stress
and cold risk for children during winter: a study in
China’s severe cold regions[J]. Buildings, 2022,
12(7): 936.
GU H, HU Q, ZHU D, et al. Research on outdoor
thermal comfort of children’s activity space in highdensity urban residential areas of Chongqing in
summer[J]. Atmosphere, 2022, 13(12): 2016.
DAVIES S, BOLEA-ALAMAÑAC B, ENDO K,
et al. Urban factors and mental health symptoms in
children of the Tokyo Early Adolescence Survey;
impact of proximity to railway stations[J]. Journal
of Transport & Health, 2023, 28: 101564.
冷红,张东禹,袁青. 寒地城市儿童健康导向的
社区规划策略研究[J]. 上海城市规划,2021(1):
23-30.
LENG Hong, ZHANG Dongyu, YUAN Qing.
Research on community planning strategy with
children’s health orientation in winter cities[J].
Shanghai Urban Planning Review, 2021(1): 23-30.
甘月朗. 中小学校空间环境健康促进影响机理
及优化设计策略研究[D]. 武汉:华中科技大学,
2022.
GAN Yuelang. Study on the influence mechanism
and optimization design strategy of space environment health promotion in primary and secondary
schools[D]. Wuhan: Huazhong University of Science
and Technology, 2022.
MCLEROY K R, BIBEAU D, STECKLER A, et
al. An ecological perspective on health promotion
programs[J]. Health Education Quarterly, 1988,
15(4): 351-377.
徐梦一,蒂姆•吉尔,毛盼,等. “儿童友好城市
(社区)”的国际认证机制与欧美相关实践及理
论发展[J]. 国际城市规划,2021,36(1):1-7.
XU Mengyi, GILL T, MAO Pan, et al. International
certification mechanism of “child friendly cities
(communities)” and related practices and theoretical
developments of European and American cities[J].
Urban Planning International, 2021, 36(1): 1-7.
施雯,黄春晓. 国内儿童友好空间研究及实践评
述[J]. 上海城市规划,2021(5):129-136.
SHI Wen, HUANG Chunxiao. Review on research
and practice of child-friendly space in China[J].
Shanghai Urban Planning Review, 2021(5): 129-136.
江文文,韩笋生. 澳大利亚儿童友好城市建设及
启示[J]. 现代城市研究,2019(1):2-7.
JIANG Wenwen, HAN Sunsheng. Experiences and
inspirations of the construction of child-friendly
cities in Australia[J]. Modern Urban Research,
2019(1): 2-7.
陈泓,孙文怡,王宇婷. “游戏计划”——纽约中
央公园儿童游乐场的系统更新[J]. 装饰,2022
(9):100-105.
CHEN Hong, SUN Wenyi, WANG Yuting. “Plan
for play”: the system renewal of playgrounds in
central park, New York City[J]. Zhuangshi, 2022(9):
100-105.
NORDSTRÖM M. Children’s views on childfriendly environments in different geographical,
cultural and social neighbourhoods[J]. Urban
Studies, 2010, 47(3): 514-528.
SAPSAĞLAM Ö, ERYILMAZ A. Building childfriendly cities for sustainable child development:
child-friendly city scale-child form[J]. Sustainability,
2024, 16(3): 1-15.
DAS R, BANERJEE A. Identifying the parameters
for assessment of child-friendliness in urban
neighborhoods in Indian cities[J]. Journal of Urban
Affairs, 2021, 45(2): 217-235.
BADLAND H, VILLANUEVA K, ALDERTON
A, et al. An urban neighbourhood framework for
realising progress towards the new urban agenda
for equitable early childhood development[J].
Children’s Geographies, 2023, 21(6): 1087-1105.
沈瑶,张馨丹,刘赛. 国际“儿童友好社区”评估
工具的转译与应用——以长沙市儿童权利现状
调研为例[J]. 城市规划,2022,46(12):45-56.
SHEN Yao, ZHANG Xindan, LIU Sai. Translation
and application of international “child-friendly
community” assessment tool: taking the investigation of the status quo of children’s rights in Changsha
as an example[J]. City Planning Review, 2022,
46(12): 45-56.
JANSSON M, HERBERT E, ZALAR A, et al.
Child-friendly environments—what, how and by
whom?[J]. Sustainability, 2022, 14(8): 4852.
HAN M J N, KIM M J. A critical review of childfriendly environments, focusing on children’s
experiential perspectives on the physical world
for sustainability[J]. Sustainability, 2018, 10(10):
3725.
齐君,董玉萍,提姆•汤森. 可供性理论在西方环
境规划设计中的应用与发展[J]. 国际城市规划,
2019,34(6):100-107.
QI Jun, DONG Yuping, TOWNSHEND T.
Application and development of affordance theory
in western environmental planning and design[J].
Urban Planning International, 2019, 34(6): 100-107.
WANG X, WHITTAKER J, KELLOM K, et al.
Integrating the built and social environment into
health assessments for maternal and child health:
creating a planning-friendly index[J]. International
Journal of Environmental Research and Public
Health, 2020, 17(24): 9224.
ANZIVINO L, CHAMPS C M D, COLOM P, et
al. An innovative approach to local development
of health promotion to reduce social inequalities in
health[J]. Sante Publique, 2018, 30(S1): 63-67.
JUNG E M, KIM E M, KANG M, et al. Children’s
environmental health indicators for low-and
middle-income countries in Asia[J]. Annals of
Global Health, 2017, 83(3-4): 530-540.
NELSON K M. Designing healthier communities
through the input of children[J]. Journal of Public
Health Management and Practice, 2008, 14(3):
266-271.
BUTTAZZONI A, PHAM J, CLARK A, et al.
Validating the perceived active school travel enablers
and barriers - child (PASTEB-C) questionnaire[J].
Public Health, 2023, 223: 117-127.
TUPPER E, MORRIS S, LAWLOR E R, et al.
Children’s experiences of care on walking and
cycling journeys between home and school in
Healthy New Towns: reframing active school
travel[J]. Health Place, 2024, 85: 103147.
ZIVIANI J, WADLEY D, WARD H, et al. A
place to play: socioeconomic and spatial factors
in children’s physical activity[J]. Australian
Occupational Therapy Journal, 2008, 55(1): 2-11.
MATISZIW T C, NILON C H, STANIS S W, et al.
The right space at the right time: the relationship
between children’s physical activity and land use/
land cover[J]. Landscape and Urban Planning,
2016, 151: 21-32.
林晨薇,韩西丽,范京. 土地开发强度对儿童户
外体力活动的影响——以深圳市为例[J]. 城市
规划,2018,42(11):97-102.
LIN Chenwei, HAN Xili, FAN Jing. Impacts of
land development intensity on children’s outdoor
physical activities: a case study of Shenzhen[J].
City Planning Review, 2018, 42(11): 97-102.
MEREDITH W J, CARDENAS-INIGUEZ C,
BERMAN M G, et al. Effects of the physical and
social environment on youth cognitive performance[J]. Developmental Psychobiology, 2022,
64(4): e22258.
王佳文,胡继元,王建龙,等. 新时代城市公共社
会福利设施规划标准研究——走向全龄友好社
会[J]. 城市规划,2024,48(2):75-83.
WANG Jiawen, HU Jiyuan, WANG Jianlong, et al.
Research on planning standards for urban public
social welfare facilities in the new era: towards
an age-friendly society[J]. City Planning Review,
2024, 48(2): 75-83.
杨震,李佳萱,刘昉,等. 城市体检背景下公共服
务设施全龄友好性评估与提升——以北京市展
览路街道为例[J]. 现代城市研究,2023(9):
96-103.
YANG Zhen, LI Jiaxuan, LIU Fang, et al. Agefriendliness evaluation and improvement of public
service facilities under the background of urban
physical examination: a case study of exhibition
road sub-district in Beijing[J]. Modern Urban
Research, 2023(9): 96-103.
KREUTZ A. Student and senior views on sustainable park design and intergenerational connection:
a case study of an urban nature park[J]. Landscape
and Urban Planning, 2024, 241: 104920.
VAN VELZEN C, HELBICH M. Green school
outdoor environments, greater equity? Assessing
environmental justice in green spaces around
Dutch primary schools[J]. Landscape and Urban
Planning, 2023, 232: 104687.
MANOUCHEHRI B, BURNS E A. Perception,
concern, competency: children’s understanding of
physical and non-physical aspects of urban environment in Iran[J]. Children’s Geographies, 2021,
21(1): 147-162.
沈瑶,廖堉珲,晋然然,等. 儿童参与视角下“校
社共建”社区花园营造模式研究[J]. 中国园林,
2021,37(5):92-97.
SHEN Yao, LIAO Yuhui, JIN Ranran, et al. Study
on the theory and practice of school-community coconstruction community garden from the perspective
of children’s participation[J]. Chinese Landscape
Architecture, 2021, 37(5): 92-97.
单杰,梅洪元,潘文特. 寒地城市儿童冬季户外
活动空间满意度影响因素探究[J]. 建筑学报,
2022(S2):86-90.
SHAN Jie, MEI Hongyuan, PAN Wente. Study on
influencing factors of children’s winter outdoor
activity space satisfaction in winter cities[J].
Architectural Journal, 2022(S2): 86-90.
高路,陈艳,苏寒松. 热带城市儿童户外活动空
间的安全设计——以三亚半山半岛户外儿童游
乐场为例[J]. 装饰,2016(11):104-105.
GAO Lu, CHEN Yan, SU Hansong. Safety design
of outdoor space for children in tropical cities:
taking outdoor children’s playground of Mid
Peninsula in Sanya for example[J]. Zhuangshi,
2016(11): 104-105.
刘赛,刘梦寒,沈瑶,等. 老旧社区中儿童空间意
象特征研究——以丰泉古井社区行动研究为例
[J]. 现代城市研究,2023(3):45-51.
LIU Sai, LIU Menghan, SHEN Yao, et al.
Research on the features of children’s space image
in old community: a case study of action research
in Fengquangujing Community[J]. Modern Urban
Research, 2023(3): 45-51.
GEORGE P, MURRAY K, CHRISTIAN H. Young
children’s use of blue spaces and the impact on their
health, development and environmental awareness:
a qualitative study from parents’ perspectives[J].
Health Promotion Journal of Australia: Official
Journal of Australian Association of Health
Promotion Professionals, 2024, 35(1): 45-56.
ESTÉVEZ-MAURIZ L, FORSSÉN J, ZACHOS G,
et al. Let the children listen: a first approximation
to the sound environment assessment of children
through a soundwalk approach[J]. International
Journal of Environmental Research and Public
Health, 2020, 17(12): 4185.
WEIR H. Spaces for children’s play and travel
close to home: the importance of threshold
spaces[J]. Children’s Geographies, 2023, 21: 1071-
1086.
SHENG H, LI X, ZENG S. Unraveling the
mediating role of plant color and familiarity on
children’s mood in urban landscape[J]. Journal of
Asian Architecture and Building Engineering,
2023, 23(6): 2091-2099.
HUANG L, SCHMID K L, ZHANG J, et al.
Association between greater residential greenness
and decreased risk of preschool myopia and
astigmatism[J]. Environmental Research, 2021,
196: 110976.
ZHOU Y, WANG M, LIN S, et al. Relationship
between children’s independent activities and
the built environment of outdoor activity space
in residential neighborhoods: a case study of
Nanjing[J]. International Journal of Environmental
Research and Public Health, 2022, 19(16): 9860.
ZHANG R, SUN F, SHEN Y, et al. Accessibility of
urban park benefits with different spatial coverage:
spatial and social inequity[J]. Applied Geography,
2021, 135(2): 102555.
KHANIAN M, Ł A S Z K I E W I C Z E ,
KRONENBERG J. Exposure to greenery during
children’s home-school walks: socio-economic
inequalities in alternative routes[J]. Transportation
Research Part D: Transport and Environment,
2024, 130: 104162.
石晓冬,邱红,甘霖. 北京市儿童友好城市建设
的系统路径与规划实践[J]. 城乡建设,2023(7):
31-37.
SHI Xiaodong, QIU Hong, GAN Lin. The systematic
pathway and planning practice for constructing a
child-friendly city in Beijing[J]. Urban and Rural
Development, 2023(7): 31-37.
ALDERTON A, O'CONNOR M, BADLAND H, et
al. Access to and quality of neighbourhood public
open space and children’s mental health outcomes:
evidence from population linked data across eight
Australian capital cities[J]. International Journal of
Environmental Research and Public Health, 2022,
19(11): 6780.
ALLAHYAR M, KAZEMI F. Effect of landscape
design elements on promoting neuropsychological
health of children[J]. Urban Forestry & Urban
Greening, 2021, 65: 127333.