自然老化型城市老年人居家养老服务需求分析与 规划策略建议——以福州市中心城区为例
Analysis of Home-based Elderly Care Service Demands and Planning Strategies for Aging-in-place Cities: A Case Study of the Central Urban Area of Fuzhou City
马 妍
福州大学建筑与城乡规划学院 副教授,硕士生导师 mayan@fzu.edu.cn
王莉莉
福州大学建筑与城乡规划学院 硕士研究生
李晋乐
福州大学建筑与城乡规划学院 硕士研究生
许 巍
福州大学建筑与城乡规划学院 硕士研究生
摘要: 随着我国老龄化进程的加速,城市人口的老龄化特征逐渐表现出不同的地域差异。自然老化型作为城市老龄化的主导模 式,其社会结构及养老需求与其他类型城市有所不同。以福州市为自然老化型城市典型案例,运用Kano模型分析、BetterWorse指数分析和回归分析法等方法,综合分析自然老化型城市老年人对各种居家养老服务的“期待性”和“依赖性”,进 而分析居家养老服务需求的优先满足顺序。结果表明:福州市老年人居家养老服务的需求呈现多样化特点,医疗卫生与日 常生活服务为全龄老年人基础性服务需求,属于必备型需求;文化娱乐与上门照料服务则为魅力型需求,且不同年龄段的 老年群体在该服务需求优先级上存在明显差异;精神慰藉和法律维权服务则属于无关型需求。据此提出应从基础保障均衡 化、文娱空间适老化、照护体系梯度化3个方面对居家养老空间进行优化。
Abstract: With the acceleration of population aging in China, the aging characteristics of urban populations are gradually showing different regional differences. As the main model of urban aging, aging-in-place cities have different social structures and elderly care demands compared to other types of cities. Taking Fuzhou City as a typical case of an aging-in-place city, this paper uses methods including Kano model analysis, Better-Worse coefficient analysis, and regression analysis to comprehensively analyze the “expectancy” and “dependence” of the elderly in aging-in-place cities on various home-based elderly care services, and then analyzes the priority order for meeting home-based elderly care service demands. The research results show that demands for home-based elderly care services among the elderly in Fuzhou present diverse characteristics. Medical and health care as well as daily life services are the basic service demands of the elderly of all ages and belong to essential demands. Cultural entertainment and home-based care services are charming demands, and there are significant differences in the priority of these service demands among elderly people of different age groups. Spiritual comfort and legal rights protection services belong to irrelevant demands. Based on these findings, this paper proposes that home-based elderly care spaces should be optimized from three aspects: balanced basic security, elderly-friendly cultural and entertainment spaces, and gradient care systems.
关键词:社区居家养老服务;需求层次;Kano模型;自然老化型
Keyword: community home-based care services; hierarchy of needs; Kano model; aging-in-place cities
中图分类号:TU984
文献标识码: A
国家统计局,国务院第七次全国人口普查领导
小组办公室. 第七次全国人口普查公报(第
五号)——人口年龄构成情况[J]. 中国统计,
2021(5):10-11.
National Bureau of Statistics, Office of the Leading
Group for the Seventh National Population Census
of the State Council. Communiqué of the Seventh
National Population Census (No.5): age composition
of the population[J]. China Statistics, 2021(5): 10-11.
Atkins M T, Tonts M. Exploring cities through a
population ageing matrix: a spatial and temporal
analysis of older adult population trends in Perth,
Australia[J]. Australian Geographer, 2015, 47(1):
65-87.
李日邦,王五一,谭见安,等. 我国人口老龄化
发展的阶段、趋势和区域差异[J]. 地理研究,
1999,18(2):113-121.
Li Ribang, Wang Wuyi, Tan Jian’an, et al. The
development stages and trend of population ageing
and its regional differences in China[J]. Geographical Research, 1999, 18(2): 113-121.
杜鹏,王武林. 论人口老龄化程度城乡差异的转
变[J]. 人口研究,2010,34(2):3-10.
Du Peng, Wang Wuhlin. The difference of urban
and rural ageing and its transition[J]. Population
Research, 2010, 34(2): 3-10.
McCarthy K F. The elderly population’s changing
spatial distribution : patterns of change since
1960[M]. Santa Monica: The RAND Corporation,
1983.
刘鉴,杨青山,张郁,等. 东北三省县级尺度人口
老龄化空间格局演变及类型划分[J]. 地理科学,
2020,40(6):918-927.
Liu Jian, Yang Qingshan, Zhang Yu, et al. Spatial
patterns evolution and classification of population
aging in the three provinces of Northeast China
based on the county scale[J]. Scientia Geographica
Sinica, 2020, 40(6): 918-927.
喻冰洁,崔叙,杨田,等. 大城市人口老龄化的时
空演化特征与规划响应——以成都市为例[J].
规划师,2024,40(3):43-52.
Yu Bingjie, Cui Xu, Yang Tian, et al. The spacetemporal evolution characteristics and planning
response of population aging in large cities: taking
Chengdu as an example[J]. Planners, 2024, 40(3):
43-52.
徐州,林孝松,罗朝杨. 重庆市人口老龄化时空
演变及空间类型研究[J]. 北京师范大学学报(自
然科学版),2019,55(6):772-779.
Xu Zhou, Lin Xiaosong, Luo Chaoyang. Temporal
spatial evolution and classification of population
aging in Chongqing[J]. Journal of Beijing Normal
University, 2019, 55(6): 772-779.
武荣伟,张佳丽,周亮,等. 人口流动视角下中国
县市人口老龄化地域类型演化及影响因素[J].
地理科学进展,2025,44(6):1213-1226.
Wu Rongwei, Zhang Jiali, Zhou Liang, et al.
Population aging in Chinese counties: change of
regional types and influencing factors from the
population mobility perspective[J]. Progress in
Geography, 2025, 44(6): 1213-1226.
王军力. 特大城市分圈层的人口老龄化时空演
变特征、模式及规划响应——以广州市为例[J].
城市建筑,2024,21(19):105-109.
Wang Junli. The spatial and temporal evolution
characteristics, patterns and planning responses of
population aging in urban subdivisions: a case of
Guangzhou[J]. Urbanism and Architecture, 2024,
21(19): 105-109.
刘涛,张家瑞,曹广忠. 人口流动对区域老龄化
进程的影响:一个方法论探讨[J]. 地理研究,
2022,41(10):2680-2696.
Liu Tao, Zhang Jiarui, Cao Guangzhong. The
effect of internal migration on regional aging: a
decomposition method[J]. Geographical Research,
2022, 41(10): 2680-2696.
梁晓璇,梁博,刘晓瑞,等. 东北三省老年家庭
空巢化的时空特征及机制探究[J]. 地理科学,
2026,46(4):889-901.
Liang Xiaoxuan, Liang Bo, Liu Xiaorui, et al.
Spatio-temporal characteristics and evolution
mechanisms of elderly empty-nest households in
northeast China[J]. Geographical Science, 2026,
46(4): 889-901.
徐蕊,安秀芳,郝卓亚,等. 农村高龄失能老人养
老服务需求现状及影响因素研究[J]. 中国卫生
事业管理,2025,42(2):186-195.
Xu Rui, An Xiufang, Hao Zhuoya, et al. Study on
the current status and influencing factors of elderly
care service needs for rural disabled elderly[J].
The Chinese Health Service Management, 2025,
42(2): 186-195.
左美云,杨艳敏. 基于不同年龄段老年群体动态
需求分析的智慧养老服务研究[J]. 四川大学学
报(哲学社会科学版),2025(3):15-27.
Zuo Meiyun, Yang Yanmin. A study of smart
senior care services: based on the dynamic needs
of different age groups[J]. Journal of Sichuan
University (Philosophy and Social Science Edition),
2025(3): 15-27.
王梦雪,柴钰霖,付国琪,等. 不同养老模式下农
村老年人养老服务需求状况研究[J]. 现代预防
医学,2024,51(15):2774-2779.
Wang Mengxue, Chai Yulin, Fu Guoqi, et al. Elderly
care service demands under different care models in
rural areas[J]. Modern Preventive Medicine, 2024,
51(15): 2774-2779.
王羽,赫宸,王晓朦. 不同居住模式下中老年人
对于居家智慧养老的需求调查研究[J]. 上海城
市规划,2024(3):31-36.
Wang Yu, He Chen, Wang Xiaomeng. Investigation
and study on the demand for smart home-based
elderly care among middle-aged and older adults
under different living arrangements[J]. Shanghai
Urban Planning Review, 2024(3): 31-36.
高秀文,唐咏. 失能老人居家社区养老服务利用
类型及影响因素分析[J]. 中国卫生事业管理,
2025,42(6):612-618.
Gao Xiuwen, Tang Yong. Analysis of the types of
home-based community care services among the
disabled older adults and its influencing factors[J].
Chinese Health Service Management, 2025, 42(6):
612-618.
杨红霞,阴其谱,伊若男,等. 中老年人智慧居家
养老服务需求现状及其影响因素[J]. 护理研究,
2023,37(6):1077-1082.
Yang Hongxia, Yin Qipu, Yi Ruonan, et al.
Status quo and influencing factors of demand
of intelligent home-based elderly care service
of middle-aged and elderly people[J]. Chinese
Nursing Research, 2023, 37(6): 1077-1082.
黄启原,李颖,许昕,等. 基于CLHLS的老年人社
区养老服务需求及影响因素研究[J]. 护理学杂
志,2021,36(3):5-9.
Huang Qiyuan, Li Ying, Xu Xin, et al. Older
adults’ needs of community elder care service in
China and the influencing factors: an empirical
research based on CLHLS[J]. Journal of Nursing
Science, 2021, 36(3): 5-9.
周建芳. 城市老人居家养老服务的有效需求及
其影响因素[J]. 北京社会科学,2022(11):
116-128.
Zhou Jianfang. A study on the effective demand
of home-based elderly care services for the urban
elderly and its influencing factors[J]. Social
Science of Beijing, 2022(11): 116-128.
李兆友,郑吉友. 农村社区居家养老服务需求强
度的实证分析——基于辽宁省S镇农村老年人的
问卷调查[J]. 社会保障研究,2016(5):18-26.
Li Zhaoyou, Zheng Jiyou. An empirical analysis of
the demand intensity of the rural community home
endowment service: based on the investigation of
rural elderly in S Town in Liaoning Province[J].
Social Security Studies, 2016(5): 18-26.
刘小春. 农村居民养老服务项目需求优先次序及
其影响因素研究[J]. 价格月刊,2020(6):79-88.
Liu Xiaochun. Research on the demand priority
and influencing factors of elderly care in rural
areas[J]. Prices Monthly, 2020(6): 79-88.
刘蕾. 基于KANO模型的农村公共服务需求分
类与供给优先序研究[J]. 财贸研究,2015,26
(6):39-46.
Liu Lei. On the supply priority of rural public
services and the demand classification with the
KANO model[J]. Finance and Trade Research,
2015, 26(6): 39-46.
蔡山彤,敖楹婧. 城市老年人居家养老服务需求
及影响因素——基于成都的社会调查[J]. 人口
与社会,2016,32(3):23-35.
Cai Shantong, Ao Yingjing. Study on service
demand at home and influencing factors of the
city elderly: based on the social investigation of
Chengdu[J]. Population and Society, 2016, 32(3):
23-35.
刘慧玲. 社区居家养老服务需求现状及对策——
以重庆市社区为例[J]. 社会福利(理论版),
2022(7):42-50.
Liu Huiling. Current situation and countermeasures
of community home care service demand: taking
Chongqing community as an example[J]. Social
Welfare (Theory Edition), 2022(7): 42-50.
王佳姝,俞蕾,仇琰,等. 城市社区老年人养老服
务需求及影响因素[J]. 中国老年学杂志,2017,
37(24):6236-6238.
Wang Jiashu, Yu Lei, Qiu Yan, et al. Elderly care
service needs and influencing factors for older
adults in urban communities[J]. Chinese Journal
of Gerontology, 2017, 37(24): 6236-6238.
胡升星,白旭,饶夫阳,等. 北京市朝阳区老年人
居家养老医疗服务需求及影响因素[J]. 医学与
社会,2018,31(7):77-80.
Hu Shengxing, Bai Xu, Rao Fuyang, et al.
Demand of elderly for home-based medical care
services and its influencing factors in Chaoyang
District of Beijing City[J]. Medicine and Society,
2018, 31(7): 77-80.
于泽浩. 北京市老年居家服务项目使用影响因
素及有效供给分析——以2015年“第四次中国
城乡老年人生活状况抽样调查”北京数据为基
础[J]. 兰州学刊,2019(7):196-208.
Yu Zehao. Factors affecting the use and effective
supply of home-based services for the elderly in
Beijing: based on the 2015 “Fourth Survey on the
Living Conditions of Urban and Rural Elderly
in China” Beijing data[J]. Lanzhou Academic
Journal, 2019(7): 196-208.
侯冰,张乐川. 社区居家养老服务需求层次及其
优先满足序列——以上海市斜土路街道为例[J].
城市问题,2017(12):4-11.
Hou Bing, Zhang Lechuan. Needs hierarchy of
community service for the old-age home care: based
on the investigation to the Xietu Road Street of
Shanghai City[J]. Urban Problems, 2017(12): 4-11.
赵丽宏. 城市居家养老生活照料体系研究[J]. 学
术交流,2007(10):123-125.
Zhao Lihong. A study on the daily living care
system for urban home-based elderly care[J].
Academic Exchange, 2007(10): 123-125.
陈小卉,杨红平. 老龄化背景下城乡规划应对研
究——以江苏为例[J]. 城市规划,2013,37(9):
17-21.
Chen Xiaohui, Yang Hongping. Urban-rural
planning in the context of population aging: a
case study on jiangsu province[J]. City Planning
Review, 2013, 37(9): 17-21.
胡刚钰,黄建中,牛强. 老龄化背景下社区服务
设施相关研究综述与启示[J].城市发展研究,
2016,23(2):78-83.
Hu Gangyu, Huang Jianzhong, Niu Qiang. Review
and revelation of the community service facilities
research under the background of aging[J]. Urban
Development Studies, 2016, 23(2): 78-83.
何静,周典,戴靓华. 基于需求理论的城市养老
生活关联设施评价体系研究[J].建筑学报,2020
(增刊2):37-44.
He Jing, Zhou Dian, Dai Lianghua. Study
on evaluation system of urban elderly living
related facilities based on demand theories[J].
Architectural Journal, 2020(S2): 37-44.
Matszler K, Hinterhuber H H. How to make
product development projects more successful by
integrating Kano’s model of customer satisfaction
into quality function deployment[J]. Technovation,
1998, 18(1): 25-38.
Mkpojiogu E O, Hashim N L. Understanding
the relationship between Kano model’s customer
satisfaction scores and self-stated requirements
importance[J]. SpringerPlus, 2016, 5(1): 197.
侯冰. 老年人社区居家养老服务需求层次及其
满足策略研究[J]. 社会保障评论,2019,3(3):
147-159.
Hou Bing. Community home-based care service
for urban elderly: demand levels and satisfying
strategy[J]. Chinese Social Security Review, 2019,
3(3): 147-159.
中华人民共和国国家发展和改革委员会. 福建:
福州市擦亮“有福之州 幸福老人”金字招牌
让每个老年人拥有幸福晚年[EB/OL]. (2025-11-
17)[2025-12-19]. https://www.ndrc.gov.cn/xwdt/
ztzl/ylyx/dxjy/202511/t20251117_1401670.html.
National Development and Reform Commission
of the People’s Republic of China. Fujian: Fuzhou
polishes the golden signboard of “blessed city,
happy older adults” to ensure a happy later life for
every older adult[EB/OL]. (2025-11-17) [2025-
12-19]. https://www.ndrc.gov.cn/xwdt/ztzl/ylyx/
dxjy/202511/t20251117_1401670.html.
叶锦涛,王建平. 特大城市老年人家庭结构、老
龄化程度与养老需求研究——以上海市为例[J].
老龄科学研究,2020,8(7):41-56.
Ye Jintao, Wang Jianping. Family structure, degree
of population aging and demand of senior care
in megacities: taking Shanghai as an example[J].
Science Research on Aging, 2020, 8(7): 41-56.
罗兴奇. 居家养老服务的结构困境及优化路
径——以上海市为例[J]. 城市问题,2017(2):
83-89.
Luo Xingqi. The structural dilemma and optimization path of home care service: taking Shanghai
City as an example[J]. Urban Problems, 2017(2):
83-89.
黄晓燕,周帅. 上海市某街道居家养老服务需求
调查[J]. 中国卫生产业,2019,16(3):1-3.
Huang Xiaoyan, Zhou Shuai. Survey on the needs
of home care services for a street in Shanghai[J].
China Health Industry, 2019, 16(3): 1-3.