国外社区规划近十五年研究进展* ——基于Citespace软件的可视化分析
Review on Community Planning Research of Foreign Countries in the Past 15 Years: A Visualized Analysis Based on Citespace Software
袁媛
山大学地理科学与规划学院 城市与区域规划系副主任 中山大学城市化研究院 副院长 广东省城市化与地理环境空间模拟重点实验室 教授，博士
林静
中山大学地理科学与规划学院 硕士研究生
柳叶
广东省建设设计研究院规划设计研究所 助理工程师，中山大学硕士
摘要: 随着中国城市社区的更新规划逐渐增多、乡村社区崛起及治理改革呼声渐高，社区将是未来中国规划师的主要工作场所之一。从文献时间分布、代表人物及文章、研究热点、研究前沿和研究内容5个方面切入，利用Citespace软件将Web of Science数据库中1999-2014年近15年间关于社区规划的1681篇论文进行可视化分析。研究发现：国外社区规划研究的爆发年份为2002年；管治、参与、可持续发展和保护等是研究的热点；体现了从早期规划探索到主题多元化并逐渐将社区规划与社会问题紧密联系的发展趋势。最后系统梳理了“社区协作和参与”、“物质规划内容”、“特殊社区”、“社区安全”、“社区情感与身份”、“社区可持续发展”、“社区复兴”、“GIS在社区规划中的应用”等8大主要研究内容，以期对我国社区规划研究和实践提供指引与借鉴。
Abstract: Community will become the major operational site of Chinese planners, accompanying with the increasing regeneration plans on urban communities and raising demands for governance on rural communities. A total of 1681 papers on community planning, from year of 1999 to 2014, in the Web of Science database are visually analyzed by Citespace, displaying in five aspects, such as time distribution of papers, representative figures and articles, research focuses, foreland of analyses and research contents. The result shows that analyses on foreign community planning erupted in 2002. Researching hot-spots includes governance, participation, sustainability and conversation in communities. It trends from exploration of community planning in earlier time and diversity of research topics to close connection with community planning and social problems in later period. Finally, this paper states eight main contents such as 'community collaboration and community participation', 'physical planning on community level', 'special community', 'community safety', 'community emotion and identity', 'community sustainable development', 'community revitalization', 'application of GIS in community planning'. It is expected to provide instructions and references to planning research and practices on communities in China.
关键词：社区规划、Citespace软件、可视化分析
Keyword: Community planning, Citespace, Visualized analysis
中图分类号：TU981
文献标识码: A
资金资助
国家自然科学基金 41071106，41330747
[1] 赵蔚，赵民. 从居住区规划到社区规划[J]. 城市规划汇刊，2002（6）：68-71，80.
ZHAO Wei, ZHAO Min .Residential Planning or Community Planning [J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2002(6):68-71, 80.
[2] 朱介鸣. 西方规划理论与中国规划实践之间的隔阂——以公众参与和社区规划为例[J].城市规划学刊，2012，b（1）：9-16.
ZHU Jieming. The Gap between Western Planning Theories and China's Planning Practice—Taking Public Participation and Community Planning as Examples[J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2012,b(1):9-16.
[3] 威廉•洛尔,张纯译. 从地方到全球:美国社区规划100年[J]. 国际城市规划，2011（2）：85-98，115.
William M. Rohe. From Local to Global:One Hundred Years of Neighborhood Planning[J]. Urban Planning International, 2011,(2):85-98,115.
[4] 胡伟. 城市规划与社区规划之辨析[J]. 城市规划汇刊，2001（1）：60-63，80.
HU Wei .Urban Planning and Community Planning [J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2001,(1):60-63,80.
[5] 徐一大，吴明伟. 从住区规划到社区规划[J]. 城市规划汇刊，2002（4）：54-55，59-80.
XU Yida, WU Mingwei .Two Words of Community Planning [J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2002(4):54-55,59-80.
[6] 刘玉亭，何深静，魏立华. 英国的社区规划及其对中国的启示[J]. 规划师，2009（3）：85-89. LIU Yuting, HE Shenjing, WEI Lihua .Community Planning of Britain and Its Enlightenment to China[J]. Planners, 2009(3):85-89.
[7] 杨辰. 街区概念的理论建构与空间实践——1840以来的法国城市社区研究[J]. 城市问题，2012（3）：79-87.
YANG Chen .Theory Construction and Spatial Practice of Communities: A Case Study of French Experience since 1840[J]. Urban Problems, 2012(3):79-87.
[8] Goldstein BE, Butler WH. Expanding the Scope and Impact of Collaborative Planning Combining Multi-Stakeholder Collaboration and Communities of Practice in a Learning Network [J]. Journal of The American Planning Association, 2010, 76(2): 238-249.
[9] Koontz TM .The Farmer, the Planner, and the Local Citizen in the Dell: How Collaborative Groups Plan for Farmland Preservation [J]. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2003, 66(1):19-34.
[10] Sirianni C. Neighborhood Planning as Collaborative Democratic Design - The Case of Seattle [J]. Journal of the American Planning Association, 2007, 73(4): 373-387.
[11] Nelson A, Pettit C. Effective Community Engagement for Sustainability: Wombat Community forest management case study [J]. Australian Geographer, 2004, 35(3):301-315.
[12] Vivek S, W. Barry M. Fostering Green Communities through Civic Engagement Community-Based Environmental Stewardship in the Portland Area [J]. Journal of the American Planning Association, 2008, 74(4):408-418.
[13] Chakrabarti S, Majumder A, Chakrabarti S. Public-community participation in household waste management in India: An operational approach [J]. Habitat International, 2008, 33(1):125-130.
[14] Damian P, Ellen B. Collaborative Planning for Clean Energy Initiatives in Small to Mid-Sized Cities [J]. Journal of the American Planning Association, 2013, 79(4): 280-294.
[15] Colin H D, Cassidy J, Gonzalo L. Truths and myths about community participation in post-disaster housing projects [J]. Habitat International, 2006, 31(1): 100-115.
[16] Linda T, George E. Public Transport Service Quality and Sustainable Development: a Community Stakeholder Perspective [J]. Sustainable Development, 2010, 18(1):51-61.
[17] McDonald NC. School Siting Contested Visions of the Community School [J]. Journal of the American Planning Association, 2010, 76(2):184-198.
[18] Pothukuchi K. Community food assessment - A first step in planning for community food security [J]. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 2004, 23(4):356-377.
[19] Jacqueline K, Dori R, Lawrence F. The Role of the Built Environment in Healthy Aging: Community Design, Physical Activity, and Health among Older Adults [J]. Journal of Planning Literature, 2012, 27(1):43-60.
[20] Nisha D B, Matthew T, Tom F. Green Health Urban Planning and the Development of Healthy and Sustainable Neighborhoods and Schools [J]. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 2014, 34(2), 113-122.
[21] Gooblar A. Outside the walls: Urban gated communities and their regulation within the British planning system. European Planning Studies, 2002, 10(3): 321-334.
[22] Therese K, Deborah S, Stevenson. Experiences of 'Community' in a Gated Residential Estate [J]. Geographical Research, 2013, 51(4):412-423.
[23] de Duren NL. Planning a la carte: The location patterns of gated communities around Buenos Aires in a decentralized planning context [J]. International Journal of Urban and Regional Research, 2006, 30(2):308-327.
[24] de Duren NRL. Gated communities as a municipal development strategy [J]. Housing Policy Debate, 2007, 18(3):607-626.
[25] Gregory D B, Karina L, Ellen G C. Is it safer behind the gates? Crime and gated communities in South Africa [J]. Journal of Housing and the Built Environment, 2014, 29(1):123-139.
[26] Manzi T, Smith-Bowers B. Gated communities as club goods: Segregation or social cohesion [J]. Housing Studies, 2005, 20(2):345-359.
[27] Lemanski C. Spaces of exclusivity or connection? Linkages between a gated community and its poorer neighbor in a Cape Town Master Plan Development [J]. Urban Studies, 2006, 43(2):397-20.
[28]Melissa R, Michelle D. Negotiating the geographies of cultural difference in local communities: two examples from suburban Melbourne [J]. Geographical Research, 2007, 45(4): 358-375.
[29] Carolina S S, Victoria A B. Traversing the Border: Community-Based Planning and Transnational Migrants [J]. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 2013, 33(3):336-347.
[30] Abramson D, Manzo L, Hou J. From ethnic enclave to multi-ethnic translocal community: Contested identities and urban design in seattle's Chinatown-International District [J]. Journal of Architectural and Planning Research, 2006, 23(4):341-360.
[31] Dan A, Lynne M, Jeffrey H. From ethnic enclave to multi-ethnic translocal community: Contested identities and urban design in settle’s Chinatown-International District [J]. Journal of Architectural and Planning Research, 2006, 23(4):341-360.
[32] Perry RW, Lindell MK. Preparedness for emergency response: Guidelines for the emergency planning process [J]. Disasters, 2003, 27(4):336-350.
[33] Naim K. Collaborative emergency management: better community organising, better public preparedness and response [J]. Disasters, 2008, 32(2):239-262.
[34] Allen KM. Community-based disaster preparedness and climate adaptation: local capacity-building in the Philippines [J]. Disasters, 2006, 30(1):81-101.
[35] David D, Diana M. Challenges for community-based adaptation: discovering the potential for transformation [J]. Journal of International Development, 2013, 25(5):640-659.
[36] Cova TJ, Johnson JP. Microsimulation of neighborhood evacuations in the urban – wildland interface [J]. Environment and Planning A, 2002, 34(12):2211-2229.
[37] Petheram L, Zander KK, Campbell BM. 'Strange changes': Indigenous perspectives of climate change and adaptation in NE Arnhem Land (Australia) [J]. Global Environmental Change-Human and Policy Dimensions, 2010, 20(4):681-692.
[38] Johanna W, Ilana A, Trevor B. Values, climate change, and implications for adaptation: Evidence from two communities in Labrador, Canada [J]. Global Environmental Change-Human and Policy Dimensions, 2013, 23(2):548-562.
[39] Farrah D G. "It Was a Real Village": Community Identity Formation among Black Middle-Class Residents in Pontchartrain Park [J]. Journal of Urban History, 2013, 39(1):36-58.
[40] Cicognani E, Pirini C, Keyes C etc. Social Participation, Sense of Community and Social Well Being: A Study on American, Italian and Iranian University students. Social Indicators Research, 2008, 89(1):97-112.
[41] Gafford F D. "It Was a Real Village": Community Identity Formation among Black Middle-Class Residents in Pontchartrain Park. Journal of Urban History, 2013, 39(1):36-58.
[42] Lin H, Luyt B. The National Library of Singapore: Creating a Sense of Community. Journal of Documentation, 2014, 70(4): 658-675.
[43] Vidal T, Berroeta H, Di Masso A etc. Place Attachment, Place Identity, Sense of Community, and Local Civic Participation in an Urban Renewal Context. Estudios De Psicologia, 2013, 34(3):275-286.
[44] Wyman M, Stein T. Examining the Linkages between Community Benefits, Place-Based Meanings, and Conservation Program Involvement: A Study Within the Community Baboon Sanctuary, Belize [J]. Society and Natural Resources, 2010, 23(6):542-556.
[45] Stewart WP, Liebert D, Larkin KW. Community identities as visions for landscape change [J]. Landscape and Urban Planning. 2003, 69(2-3):315-334.
[46] Berke PR. Does sustainable development offer a new direction for planning? Challenges for the twenty-first century [J]. Journal of Planning Literature, 2002, 17(1):21-36.
[47] Churchill CJ, Baetz BW. Development of decision support system for sustainable community design [J]. Journal of Urban Planning and Development-ASCE, 1999, 125(1):17-35.
[48] Berg PG. Sustainability resources in Swedish townscape neighbourhoods - Results from the model project Hagaby and comparisons with three common residential areas [J]. Landscape and Urban Planning, 2004, 68(1):29-52.
[49] Raco M. Sustainable development, rolled-out neoliberalism and sustainable communities [J]. Antipode, 2005, 37(2): 324-347.
[50] Carla C. The sustainable communities experiment in the United States - Insights from three federal-level initiatives [J]. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 2007, 26(4):435-449.
[51] Freeman L, Braconi F. Gentrification and displacement - New York City in the 1990s [J]. Journal of the American Planning Association, 2004, 70(1):39-52.
[52] Ha SK. Housing renewal and neighborhood change as a gentrification process in Seoul [J]. Cities, 2004, 21(5):381-389.
[53] Darren S. The Politics of Studentification and '(Un) balanced' Urban Populations: Lessons for Gentrification and Sustainable Communities [J]. Urban Studies, 2008, 45(12):2541-2564.
[54] Carl G. Art Spaces in Community and Economic Development: Connections to Neighborhoods, Artists, and the Cultural Economy [J]. Journal of Planning Education and Research, 2011, 31(1):74-85.
[55] Elwood S, Leitner H. GIS and spatial knowledge production for neighborhood revitalization: Negotiating state priorities and neighborhood visions [J]. Journal of Urban Affairs, 2003, 25(2):139-157.
[56] Wood J. 'How green is my valley?'Desktop geographic information systems as a community-based participatory mapping tool [J]. Area, 2005, 37(2):159-170.
[57] McCall MK, Minang PA. Assessing participatory GIS for community-based natural resource management: claiming community forests in Cameroon [J]. Geographical Journal, 2005, 171(4):340-356.
[58] Dennis SF. Prospects for qualitative GIS at the intersection of youth development and participatory urban planning [J]. Environment and Planning A, 2006, 38(11):2039-2054.
[59] Frank KI. The potential of youth participation in planning [J]. Journal of Planning Literature, 2006, 20(4):351-371.
[60] Karl A, Richard R, Anton E etc. The Geo Citizen-approach: community-based spatial planning - an Ecuadorian case study [J]. Cartography and Geographic Information Science, 2014, 41(3):248-259.
[61] 杨贵庆. 未来十年上海大都市住房问题和社区规划[J]. 城市规划汇刊，2000（4）：63-68.
YANG Guiqing. Housing Problem and Community Planning in the Next 10 Years of Metropolitan Shanghai[J]. Urban Planning Forum , 2000(4):63-68.
[62] 孙施文，邓永成. 开展具有中国特色的社区规划——以上海市为例[J]. 城市规划汇刊，2001（6）：16-18，51.
SUN Shiwen, DENG Yongcheng. Develop the Characteristic Community Planning of China--Taking Shanghai as the case[J]. Urban Planning Forum,2001(6):16-18,51.
[63] 李京生，王学兰. 关于上海市嘉定区社区划分的研究[J]. 上海城市规划，2007（4）：16-19. LI Jingsheng, WANG Xuelan. WANG Xuelan. Research on Community Space Organizing of Jiading District in Shanghai [J]. Shanghai Urban Planning Review,2007(4):16-19.
[64] 袁媛，陈金城. 低收入社区的规划协作机制研究——以广州市同德街规划为例[J]. 城市规划学刊，2015, (1).
YUAN Yuan, CHEN Jincheng. The Collaborative Mechanism in Urban Planning of Low-income Community—A Case Study of Regulatory Plan of Tongdejie of Guangzhou. Urban Planning Forum, 2015, (1).
[65] 吴丹，王卫城. 深圳社区规划师制度的模式研究[J]. 规划师，2013，29（9）：36-40.
WU Dan, WANG Weicheng. Shenzhen Community Planner Pattern Research [J]. Planners, 2013,29(9):36-40.
[66] 袁媛等. 社区规划师: 技术员 or 协调员[J]. 城市规划，2014，38（11）：30-36.
YUAN Yuan，et al. Community Planner: Technician or Coordinator [J] .City Planning Review, 2014,38(11):30-36.
