资源型城市转型视角下的城镇开发边界研究 ——以铜川市为例
Research on the Urban Development Boundary from the Perspective of Resource-based City Transition: A Case Study of Tongchuan
王海涛
陕西省城乡规划设计研究院 工程师，硕士
陈 健
陕西省城乡规划设计研究院 研究中心主任，高级工程师，硕士
宋美娜
陕西省城乡规划设计研究院 助理工程师，硕士
王 楠
中国科学院大学 中国科学院地理科学与资源研究所 博士研究生
魏 博
陕西省城乡规划设计研究院 副院长，教授级高级工程师
摘要: 随着生态文明建设的稳步推进和机构改革方案的落实，建立空间规划编制体系与划定城镇开发边界将成为限制城镇无序扩张的重要政策工具。以铜川市城镇开发边界划定为例，从资源型城市转型的视角提出城镇开发边界划定方法和策略，以期为西部地区及资源型城市划定城镇开发边界提供借鉴。针对资源型城市的特征，提出以下策略：（1）从城市转型和产业转型两大视角，提出资源型城市转型发展的生态、服务、交通、产业4大导向原则；（2）基于西部城市环境脆弱和资源型城市特点，在生态敏感性分析的基础上对城镇建设用地进行增长模拟，并对比在蔓延趋势下城镇建设用地增长模拟的差异及问题；（3）基于多规融合统筹全域空间的各种控制线，并针对资源型城市独立工矿区的开发边界提出相应对策。
Abstract: With the continuous advancement of ecological civilization and the implementation of institutional reform programs, the establishment of a spatial planning system and the delineation of urban development boundaries will become important policy tools for restricting urban dislocation. Taking the delineation of the urban development boundary of Tongchuan City as an example, this paper proposes methods and strategies for delineating the urban development boundaries from the perspective of the transformation of resource-based cities, hoping to provide reference for the demarcation of urban development boundaries in the western regions and resource-based cities. According to the characteristics of resource-based cities, this paper proposes the following strategies. Firstly, from the perspectives of urban transformation and industrial transformation, four guiding principles for resource-based cities in ecology, services, transportation, and industry are proposed. Secondly, considering the fragile environment of western cities and the characteristics of resource-based cities, the urban construction space is simulated by growth based on the analysis of ecological susceptibility. The differences and problems in the simulation of urban construction land growth under the trend of spread are contrasted. Thirdly, various types of spatial control lines have been considered into the delineation of urban development boundaries. Some corresponding countermeasures for the development boundaries of independent industrial and mining areas in resource-based cities have been put forward as well.
关键词：城镇开发边界 | 资源型城市 | 转型发展 | 空间增长模拟
Keyword: Urban development boundary | Resource-based city | Transformation and development | Spatial growth simulation
中图分类号：TU981
文献标识码: A
NELSON A C, DUNCAN J B. Growth management: principles and practice[M]. Chicago IL: American Planning Association, 1995.
STALEY S R, EDGENS J D, MILDNER G C S. A line in the land: urban-growth boundaries, smart growth, and housing affordability[J]. Policy Study No. 263, Reason Public Policy Institute, 1999.
张兵，林永新，刘宛，等. “城市开发边界”政策与国家的空间治理[J]. 城市规划学刊，2014（3）：20-27.
ZHANG Bing, LIN Yongxin, LIU Wan, et al. Debate on urban development boundary: the perspective of spatial governance in China[J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2014 (3): 20-27.
METRO. Urban growth boundary: frequently asked questions [DB/OL]. http://topaz.metro-region.org, 2002.
赵之枫，巩冉冉，张健. 我国城市开发边界划定模式比较研究[J]. 规划师，2017（7）：105-111.
ZHAO Zhifeng, GONG Ranran, ZHANG Jian. A comparative study Of China’s urban development boundary delimitation[J]. Planners, 2017 (7): 105-111.
吕斌，徐勤政. 我国应用城市增长边界（UGB）的技术与制度问题探讨[C]//规划创新——2010 中国城市规划年会论文集，2010.
LYU Bin, XU Qinzheng. Discussion on the technology and system of applying urban growth boundary (UGB) in China[C]//2010 China Urban Planning Annual Conference Proceedings, 2010.
胡飞，何灵聪，杨昔. 规土合一、三线统筹、划管结合—武汉城市开发边界划定实践[J]. 规划师，2016（6）：31-37.
HU Fei, HE Lingcong, YANG Xi. Urban planning and land use plan integration, three lines coordination, planning and management combination: Wuhan urban development boundary practice[J]. Planners, 2016 (6): 31-37.
张勤，华芳，王沈玉. 杭州城市开发边界划定与实施研究[J]. 城市规划学刊，2016（1）：28-36.
ZHANG Qin, HUA Fang, WANG Shenyu. A study on the delimitation and implementation of urban development boundary in Hangzhou[J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2016 (1): 28-36.
张勤. 杭州城市开发边界划定与实施的实践探索[J]. 城市规划，2017（3）：15-18，76.
ZHANG Qin. Practice and exploration of the delimitation and implementation of the urban development boundary in Hangzhou[J]. City Planning Review, 2017 (3): 15-18, 76.
黄慧明，CASELLA S，FAICP PP. 美国“精明增长”的策略、案例及在中国的应用思考[J]. 现代城市研究，2007（5）：19-28.
HUANG Huiming, CASELLA S，FAICP PP. Main policy and cases of smart growth, consideration on how to apply in China megalopolis[J]. Modern Urban Research, 2007 (5): 19-28.
陈明，等. 基于省域视角的国土空间规划编制研究和情景分析[M]. 北京：商务印书馆，2017.
CHEN Ming, et al. Spatial plan-making and scenario analysis from a provincial perspective[M]. Beijing: The Commercial Press, 2017.
黄明华，田晓晴. 关于新版《城市规划编制办法》中城市增长边界的思考[J]. 规划师，2008（6）：13-16.
HUANG Minghua, TIAN Xiaoqing. Reflection on urban growth boundary in the new urban planning formulation means[J]. Planners, 2008 (6): 13-16.
程永辉，刘科伟，赵丹，等. “多规合一”下城市开发边界划定的若干问题探讨[J]. 城市发展研究，2015，22（7）：52-57.
CHENG Yonghui, LIU Kewei, ZHAO Dan, et al. The discussion of questions regarding delimitation of urban development boundary based on multiple plans integration[J]. Urban Development Studies, 2015, 22 (7): 52-57.
林坚，乔治洋，叶子君. 城市开发边界的“划”与“用”——我国14个大城市开发边界划定试点进展分析与思考[J]. 城市规划学刊，2017（2）：37-43.
LIN Jian, QIAO Zhiyang, YE Zijun. Delimitation and implementation of urban growth boundary: analysis and thoughts on the practice in 14 pilot cities in China[J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2017 (2): 37-43.
沈思思，陈健，耿楠森，等. 快速城镇化地区的城市开发边界划定方法探索——以榆林市为例[J]. 城市发展研究，2015（6）：103-111.
SHEN Sisi, CHEN Jian, GENG Nansen, et al.Exploring the defining method of urban growth boundary in rapid urbanization area: taking Yulin City as example[J]. Urban Development Studies, 2015 (6): 103-111.
龙小凤，白娟，孙衍龙. 西部城市开发边界划定的思路与西安实践[J]. 规划师，2016，32（6）：16-22.
LONG Xiaofeng, BAI Juan, SUN Yanlong. Western Chinese urban development boundary idea and Xi'an's practice[J]. Planners, 2016, 32 (6): 16-22.
俞孔坚，李迪华，韩西丽. 论“反规划”[J]. 城市规划，2005（9）：64-69.
YU Kongjian, LI Dihua, HAN Xili. On the negative planning[J]. City Planning Review, 2005 (9): 64-69.
苏建忠，魏清泉，郭恒亮. 广州市的蔓延机理与调控[J]. 地理学报，2005（7）：626-636.
SU Jianzhong, WEI Qingquan, GUO Hengliang. The mechanism and adjustment of urban sprawl of Guangzhou [J]. Acta Geographica Sinica, 2005 (7): 626-636.
杨建军，周文，钱颖. 城市增长边界的性质及划定方法探讨——杭州市生态带保护与控制规划实践[J]. 华中建筑，2010，28（1）：122-125.
YANG Jianjun, QIAN Wen, QIAN Ying. Discussion on the character and defined methods of urban growth boundary: a case study of the protection and control planning of ecological cological zone in Hangzhou[J]. Huazhong Architecture, 2010, 28 (1): 122-125.
王颖，顾朝林，李晓江. 中外城市增长边界研究进展[J]. 国际城市规划，2014（4）：1-11.
WANG Ying, GU Chaolin, LI Xiaojiang. Research progress of urban growth boundary at home and abroad[J]. Urban Planning International, 2014 (4): 1-11.
DANIELS T. When city and country collide: managing growth in the metropolitan fringe[M]. Washington DC: Island Press, 1999.
JUN M J. The effects of Portland's urban growth boundary on urban development patterns and commuting[J]. Urban Studies, 2004, 41 (7): 1333-1348.
尹海伟，孔繁花. 城市与区域规划空间分析实验教程[M]. 南京：东南大学出版社，2014.
YIN Haiwei, KONG Fanhua. Lab manual for spatial analysis in urban and regional planning[M]. Nanjing: Southeast University Press, 2014.
井梅秀，李晶. 基于CA-Markov模型的关中——天水经济区土地利用变化动态模拟[J]. 陕西师范大学学报（自然科学版），2013（1）：99-103.
JING Meixiu, LI Jing. The dynamic simulation of the land use change in Guanzhou-Tianshui economic zone based on CA-Markov model[J]. Journal of Shanxi Normal University (Natural Science Edition), 2013 (1): 99-103.
