高速铁路可达性对区域、城市和车站层面土地使用的影响*——基于研究综述的评价框架
The Impact of HSR Accessibility on Regional, Local and Station Level Land Use: An Evaluation Framework Based on Literature Review
许 劼
上海城建职业学院 副教授，高级工程师 复旦大学社会学流动站 博士后
摘要: 相关理论和实证研究表明，高铁对于城市用地发展具有深远的影响，并会带来城市用地发展的不平衡。然而，用地变化能在多大程度上归因于可达性，结论差异性较大，尚没有定论。为了将现有聚焦于结论的文献综述转型为注重研究方法和变量，追溯3个空间层面的研究，分离可达性和其他要素，并分析在不同背景下实证研究结论差异的原因。目前大部分研究方法可以归纳为4类：情景比较、分组对照、回归模型和离散选择模型。同时，可达性指标包括定性分析、影响区划分、单个指标、综合指标和成组指标。最后，推荐采用基于实证的纵向研究，选取与研究目的相符的弹性指标。
Abstract: Theoretical and empirical studies have found that high-speed rail (HSR) has profound impacts on urban land use development. Most studies revealed inequity development brought about by HSR. However, the consensus has not been reached concerning the extent to which the observed urban land use changes can be attributed to accessibility. To turn from current literature reviews focusing on conclusions to methodologies and variables, this paper traces different research approaches on three geographic scopes, separates the effects of accessibility from other factors and sheds light on the reason for controversial conclusions among case studies under specific backgrounds. To date, most studies addressing the relationship between HSR accessibility and land use fall into four categories of research methods: scenario comparison, group contrast, linear regression models, and discrete choice models, whilst accessibility indicators include descriptive analysis, influence zone, single index, integrated index and grouped indexes. Finally, a longitudinal study applying elastic evaluation indicators in accordance with research purpose is recommended.
关键词：高铁可达性；土地利用；评价框架
Keyword: HSR accessibility; land use; evaluation framework
中图分类号：TU981
文献标识码: A
资金资助
上海城建职业学院校级科研课题 “上海—邻沪地区网络腹地研究” cjky202114
RADOPOULOU S, MELIBAEVA S, HUANG T. Literature review of papers relevant to the topic of development impacts and economic evaluation methods of high-speed rail[R]. MIT ESD working paper series, 2011.
CHEN C, HALL P. The wider spatial-economic impacts of high-speed trains: a comparative case study of Manchester and Lille sub-regions[J]. Journal of Transport Geography, 2012, 24: 89-110.
CHENG Y, LOO B, VICKERMAN R. High-speed-rail networks, economic integration and regional specialization in China and Europe[J]. Travel Behavior and Society, 2015, 2: 1-14.
WILLIGERS J, VAN WEE B. High-speed rail and office location choices: a stated choice experiment for the Netherlands[J]. Journal of Transport Geography, 2011, 19: 745-754.
GUTIERREZ J. Location, economic potential and daily accessibility: an analysis of the accessibility impact of the high-speed line Madrid-Barcelona-French border[J]. Journal of Transport Geography, 2001, 9(4): 229-242.
SANDS B. The development effects of high-speed rail stations and implications for California[R]//RADOPOULOU S, MELIBAEVA S, HUANG T, et al. Literature review of papers relevant to the topic of development impacts and economic evaluation methods of High-Speed Rail (HSR). Cambridge: MIT Engineering Systems Division, 2011.
KNOX S. Can a high speed rail line in the UK help to close the productivity gap between London & the South East and the Regions, and boost economic growth?[J]. Transport Planning Society, 2006: 51.
HANSEN W. How accessibility shapes land-use[J]. Journal of the American Institute of Planners, 1959, 25(1): 73-76.
LITMAN T. Generated traffic and induced travel[J]. The Journal of Institute of Transportation Engineers, 2001, 71(4): 38-47.
郭伟，曾祥静，许天骏. 高铁发展、空间溢出与区域旅游经济非均衡动态演进[J]. 统计与决策，2020（10）：123-127.
GUO Wei, ZENG Xiangjing, XU Tianjun. HSR, spillover effects and the unbalanced development of regional tourism[J]. Statistics and Decision, 2020(10): 123-127.
罗震东，朱查松，薛雯雯. 基于高铁客流的长江三角洲空间结构再审视[J]. 上海城市规划，2015（4）：74-80.
LUO Zhendong, ZHU Chasong, XUE Wenwen. The analysis on spatial structure of Yangtze River Delta based on passenger flow of high-speed railway[J]. Shanghai Urban Planning Review, 2015(4): 74-80.
马光荣，程小萌，杨恩艳. 交通基础设施如何促进资本流动[J]. 中国工业经济，2020（6）： 5-23.
MA Guangrong, CHENG Xiaomeng, YANG Enyan. How does transportation infrastructure affect capital flows: a study from high-speed rail and cross-region investment of listed companies[J]. Chinese Industry Economics, 2020(6): 5-23.
HOU Q, LI S. Transport infrastructure development and changing spatial accessibility in the Greater Pearl River Delta, China, 1990-2020[J]. Journal of Transport Geography, 2011, 19: 1350-1360.
YU M, FAN W. Accessibility impact of future high speed rail corridor on the piedmont Atlantic megaregion[J]. Journal of Transport Geography, 2018, 73: 1-12.
BRUINSMA F, RIETVELD P. Urban agglomerations in European infrastructure networks[J]. Urban Studies, 1993, 30(6): 919-934.
SASAKI K, OHASHI T, ANDO A. High-speed rail transit impact on regional systems: does the Shinkansen contribute to dispersion?[J]. The Annals of Regional Science, 1997, 31: 77-98.
HERNANDEZ A, JIMENEZ J. Does high-speed rail generate spillovers on local budgets?[J]. Transport Policy, 2014, 35: 211-219.
CHEN C, HALL P. The impacts of high-speed trains on British economic geography: a study of the UK's InterCity 125/225 and its effects[J]. Journal of Transport Geography, 2011, 19: 689-704.
BERNARD A B, MOXNES A, SAITO Y U. Production networks, geography and firm performance[J]. Journal of Political Economy, 2019, 127(2): 639-688.
CHARNOZ P, LELARGE C, TREVIEN C. Communication costs and the internal organization of multi-plant businesses: evidence from the impact of the French high-speed rail[J]. The Economic Journal, 2018, 128(10): 949-994.
URENA J, MENERAULT P, GARMENDIA M. The high-speed rail challenge for big intermediate cities: a national, regional and local perspective[J]. Cities, 2009, 26: 266-279.
黄振宇，吴立春. 京沪高铁对沿线城市经济的影响[J]. 宏观经济研究，2020（2）：165-175.
HUANG Zhenyu, WU Lichun. The influence of Beijing-Shanghai HSR on regional economic growth along the line[J]. Macroeconomics, 2020(2): 165-175.
WANG L. High-speed rail services development and regional accessibility restructuring in megaregions: a case of the Yangtze River Delta, China[J]. Transport Policy, 2018, 72: 34-44.
LIU L, ZHANG M. High-speed rail impacts on travel times, accessibility, and economic productivity: a benchmarking analysis in city-cluster regions of China[J]. Journal of Transport Geography, 2018, 73: 25-40.
SHAW S, FANG Z, LU S, et al. Impacts of high speed rail on railroad network accessibility in China[J]. Journal of Transport Geography, 2014, 40: 112-122.
方大春，孙明月. 高速铁路建设对我国城市空间结构影响研究——以京广高铁沿线城市为例[J]. 区域经济评论，2014（3）：136-141.
FANG Dachun, SUN Mingyue. The influence of HSR on urban spatial structure: a case study of cities alongside Beijing-Guangzhou HSR[J]. Regional Economic Review, 2014(3): 136-141.
VICKERMAN R W, SPIEKERMANN K, WEGENER M. Accessibility and regional development in Europe[J]. Regional Studies, 1999, 33: 1-15.
GARMENDIA M, RIBALAYGUA C, URENA J M. High speed rail: implication for cities[J]. Cities, 2012, 29(2): 26-31.
鲁万波，贾婧. 高速铁路、城市发展与区域经济发展不平等——来自中国的经验数据[J]. 华东经济管理，2018，32（2）：5-14.
LU Wanbo, JIA Jing. HSR, urban development and regional disparity: evidence from China[J]. East China Economic Management, 2018, 32(2): 5-14.
POL P. A renaissance of stations, railways and cities: economic effects, development strategies and organizational issues of European high-speed-train stations[R]. DUP Science, 2002.
VICKERMAN R. High-speed rail and regional development: the case of intermediate stations[J]. Journal of Transport Geography, 2015, 42: 157-165.
GRAHAM D J. Agglomeration, productivity and transport investment[J]. Journal of Transport Economics and Policy, 2007, 41: 1-27.
BONNAFOUS A. The regional impact of the TGV[J]. Transportation, 1987, 14(2): 127-137.
HALL P. Magic carpets and seamless webs: opportunities and constraints for high-speed trains in Europe[J]. Built Environment, 2009, 35: 59-69.
赵倩，陈国伟. 高铁站区位对周边地区开发的影响研究——基于京沪线和武广线的实证分析[J]. 城市规划，2015，39（7）：50-55.
ZHAO Qian, CHEN Guowei. Influence of HSR station location on the development of surrounding areas: a case study of Beijing-Shanghai HSR and Wuhan-Guangzhou HSR[J]. City Planning Review, 2015, 39(7): 50-55.
KIM K. High-speed rail developments and spatial restructuring[J]. Cities, 2000, 17(4): 251-262.
SHEN Y, SILVA J, MARTINEZ L. HSR station location choice and its local land use impacts on small cities: a case study of Aveiro, Portugal[J]. Social and Behavioral Sciences, 2014, 111: 470-479.
BASSE R. A constrained cellular automata model to simulate the potential effects of high-speed train stations on land-use dynamics in trans-border regions[J]. Journal of Transport Geography, 2013, 32: 23-37.
ANDERSSON D, SHYR O, FU J. Does high-speed rail accessibility influence residential property price? Hedonic estimates from southern Taiwan[J]. Journal of Transport Geography, 2010, 18: 166-174.
CHEN Z, ZHOU Y, HAYNES K. Change in land use structure in urban China: does the development of high-speed rail make a difference[J]. Land Use Policy, 2020(8): 1-19.
SHEN Y, SILVA J, MARINEZ L. Assessing high-speed rail's impacts on land cover change in large urban areas based on spatial mixed logit methods: a case study of Madrid Atocha railway station from 1990 to 2006[J]. Journal of Transport Geography, 2014, 41: 184-196.
TODOROVICH P, SCHNED D, LANE R. High-speed rail (policy focus report): international lessons for U.S. policy makers[M]. Cambridge: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy, 2011.
YIN M, BERTOLINI L, DUAN J. The effects of the high-speed railway on urban development: international experience and potential implications for China[J]. Progress in Planning, 2015, 98: 1-52.
THOMPSON I B. The production of urban space by the train a Grande Vitesse: three case studies of Gares-bis[J]. Modern and Contemporary France, 1998, 6: 21-32.
LONG M, MENG X, LI G. Functional division research of railway network system along the Beijing-Shanghai Railway[J]. Geography Research, 2016, 35: 1701-1713.
LI Z, XU H. High-speed railroads and economic geography: evidence from Japan[J]. Journal of Regional Science, 2018, 58: 1-23.
MATAS A, RAYMOND J, ROIG J. Evaluating the impacts of HSR stations on the creation of firms[J]. Transport Policy, 2020, 99: 396-404.
BRUINSMA F, PELS E, PRIEMUS H, et al. Railway development: impacts on urban dynamics[M]. Heidelberg: Physica-Verlag, 2008.
BERTOLINI K. Spatial development patterns and public transport: the application of an analytical model in the Netherlands[J]. Planning Practice and Research, 1999, 14(2): 199-210.
JUCHELKA R. Bahnhof und Bahnhofsumfeld—ein Standortkomplex im Wandel[J]. Standort, 2002, 26(1): 12-16.
SUNG H, CHOI K, LEE S, et al. Exploring the impacts of land use by service coverage and station-level accessibility on rail transit ridership[J]. Journal of Transport Geography, 2014, 36: 134-140.
王兰，王灿，陈晨. 高铁站点周边地区的发展与规划——基于京沪高铁的实证分析[J]. 城市规划学刊，2014（4）：31-37.
WANG Lan, WANG Can, CHEN Chen. Development and planning of the surrounding area of high-speed rail stations: based on empirical study of Beijing-Shanghai Line[J]. Urban Planning Forum, 2014(4): 31-37.
SCHUTZ E. Stadtentwicklung durch Hochgeschwindigkeitsverkehr, Konzeptionelle und Methodische Absatzezum Umgangmit den Raumwirkungen des schienengebunden Personen-Hochgeschwindigkeitsverkehr (HGV) als Beitrag zur Losung von Problemen der Stadtentwicklung[J]. Informationen zur Raument-wicklungs, 1998(6): 369-383.
PRIEMUS H. HST railway stations as dynamic nodes in urban networks[C]//Proceedings of the Conference of Land Use and Transportation Planning in Urban China. Beijing, 2006.
SORENSEN A. Land readjustment and metropolitan growth: an examination of suburban land development and urban sprawl in the Tokyo metropolitan area[J]. Progress in Planning, 2000, 53: 217-330.
林辰辉. 我国高铁枢纽站区开发的影响因素与功能类型研究[D]. 北京：中国城市规划设计研究院，2011.
LIN Chenhui. Impact factors and function type of HSR station are development in China[D]. Beijing: China Academy of Urban Planning and Design, 2011.
DUBE J, THERIAULT M, ROSIERS F. Commuter rail accessibility and house values: the case of the Montreal South Shore, Canada, 1992-2009[J]. Transportation Research Part A, 2013, 54: 49-66.
IMMERGLUCK D. Large redevelopment initiatives, housing values and gentrification: the case of the Atlanta Beltline[J]. Urban Studies, 2009, 46 (8): 1723-1745.
周曦. 高铁站区开发对土地价值的影响研究[D]. 北京：北京交通大学，2016.
ZHOU Xi. Study on the influence of high-speed railway station development to the value of land[D]. Beijing: Beijing Jiaotong University, 2016.
王丽，曹有挥，刘可文，等. 高铁站区产业空间分布及集聚特征——以沪宁城际高铁南京站为例[J]. 地理科学，2012，32（3）：301-307.
WANG Li, CAO Youhui, LIU Kewen, et al. Spatial distribution and clusters of industry nearby high-speed rail station: the case of Nanjing Station, Shanghai-Nanjing Motor Train[J]. Scientia Geographica Sinica, 2012, 32(3): 301-307.
HESS D, ALMEIDA T. Impact of proximity to light rail rapid transit on station-area property values in Buffalo, New York[J]. Urban Studies, 2007, 44(5): 1041-1068.
CHEN Z, HAYNES K. Impact of high speed rail on housing values: an observation from the Beijing-Shanghai line[J]. Journal of Transport Geography, 2015, 43: 91-100.
