非中心城市高铁可达性与站区空间发展不协调性——基于“节点—场所”模型的评估
The Inconsistency Between High-speed Railway Accessibility and Spatial Development of Station Areas in Non-central Cities: Evaluation Based on "Node-Place" Model
卢桂伊
武汉理工大学土木工程与建筑学院硕士
徐 涛
武汉理工大学土木工程与建筑学院副教授，博士
摘要: 由于区域中非中心城市往往缺乏对高速铁路外部效应的合理认知，导致站区空间开发成效与规划预期不相符。优化“节点—场所”模型，分析高铁站节点特征与站区空间发展、功能培育两方面场所特征的关系，揭示高铁可达性变化和站区场所发展的不协调特征。对比沪蓉高铁线湖北段12个非区域中心城市高铁站区的发展成效，发现高铁可达性的提升并不能增加站区的发展动力，多数非中心城市高铁站区的土地开发规模、服务功能发育远低于规划预期，仅有少数旅游、休闲等特色产业突出的城市高铁站区发展达成部分规划目标。对非中心城市高铁站区的规划建设提出建议，包括结合城市产业科学确定站区定位和规模，合理组织站区空间，促进客流集聚效应外溢等。
Abstract: Non-central cities in the region often fail to recognize the external effects of high-speed railroads, and the spatial development of station areas is not in line with planning expectations. This paper optimizes the "node-place" model to measure the node and the place characteristics of the station area from the perspective of spatial development and functional cultivation, revealing the uncoordinated characteristics of high-speed rail accessibility changes and place development of station areas in non-central cities. A comparative analysis is conducted on the planning expectations and development effectiveness for 12 stations in non-central cities of Hubei section of the Shanghai-Chengdu High-speed Railway. It is found that the improved accessibility brought by high-speed rail does not in crease the spatial development momentum of station areas. In most non-central cities, the scale of land development and service function development of high-speed rail station area is far below the planning expectation, and only a few cities with prominent tourism,leisure and other featured industries achieve part of the planning target for the spatial development of high-speed rail station area.Two suggestions are put forward: to determine the positioning and scale of the station area scientifically by combining with urban industries and organize the space of the station area reasonably, and to promote the spillover effect of passenger flow concentration.
关键词：“节点—场所”模型；高铁站区；时空可达性；空间发展；功能培育
Keyword: "node-place" model; high-speed railway station area; space-time accessibility; spatial development; functional cultivation
中图分类号：TU984
文献标识码: A
史官清，张先平，秦迪. 我国高铁新城的使命缺失与建设建议[J]. 城市发展研究，2014，21（10）：1-5.
SHI Guanqing, ZHANG Xianping, QIN Di. The missing missions and constructive proposal of China's HSR new town[J]. Urban Development Research, 2014, 21(10): 1-5.
王缉宪，林辰辉. 高速铁路对城市空间演变的影响：基于中国特征的分析思路[J]. 国际城市规划，2011，26（1）：16-23.
WANG Jixian, LIN Chenhui. High-speed rail and its impacts on the urban spatial dynamics in China:the background and analytical framework[J]. Urban Planning International, 2011, 26(1): 16-23.
郭源园，杨林川，崔叙. 高铁枢纽站“站—城”融合的概念框架与思考[J]. 现代城市研究，2020（9）：10-17.
GUO Yuanyuan, YANG Linchuan, CUI Xu. "Station City" synergy of high-speed railway hub[J]. Modern Urban Research, 2020(9): 10-17.林辰辉. 我国高铁枢纽站区开发的影响因素研究[J]. 国际城市规划，2011，26（6）：72-77.
LIN Chenhui. Research of impact factors of high speed railways hub area development in China[J].Urban Planning International, 2011, 26(6): 72-77.
郑德高，杜宝东. 寻求节点交通价值与城市功能价值的平衡——探讨国内外高铁车站与机场等交通枢纽地区发展的理论与实践[J]. 国际城市规划，2007（1）：72-76.
ZHENG Degao, DU Baodong. Looking for the balance between transport value of node and functional value of city—discussing theory and practice in the development of airport area and high speed rail station area[J]. Urban Planning International, 2007(1): 72-76.
宋文杰，朱青，朱月梅，等. 高铁对不同规模城市发展的影响[J]. 经济地理，2015，35（10）：57-63.
SONG Wenjie, ZHU Qing, ZHU Yuemei, et al. The impacts of high speed railways for different scale cities[J]. Economic Geography, 2015, 35(10): 57-63.
张颖. 京沪高铁对沿线区域旅游业发展的影响：抑制还是促进[J]. 经济研究导刊，2020（7）：150-152.
ZHANG Ying. The impact of Beijing-Shanghai High-speed Railway on the development of regional tourism along the line: inhibition or promotion[J].Economic Research Guide, 2020(7): 150-152.
任晓红，王钰，但婷. 高铁开通对非中心城市经济增长的影响[J]. 城市问题，2020，294（1）：91-96.
REN Xiaohong, WANG Yu, DAN Ting. The impact of the opening of high-speed railway on the economic growth of small and medium-sizedcities[J]. Urban Issues, 2020, 294(1): 91-96.
宋文杰，史煜瑾，朱青，等. 基于节点—场所模型的高铁站点地区规划评价——以长三角地区为例[J]. 经济地理，2016，36（10）：18-25，38.
SONG Wenjie, SHI Yujin, ZHU Qing, et al. Evaluation on planning of high-speed rail station area based on node-place model in Yangtze River Delta Area[J].Economic Geography, 2016, 36(10): 18-25, 38.
许闻博，王兴平. 高铁站点地区空间开发特征研究——基于京沪高铁沿线案例的实证分析[J]. 城市规划学刊，2016（1）：72-79.
XU Wenbo, WANG Xingping. A study on characteristics of spatial development and construction of high-speed railway station areas - an empirical analysis based on the case of Beijing-Shanghai High speed Railway Line[J]. Urban Planning Forum,2016(1): 72-79.
王兰. 高速铁路对城市空间影响的研究框架及实证[J]. 规划师，2011，27（7）：13-19.
WANG Lan. Research framework of high-speed railway impact on urban space[J]. Planners, 2011, 27(7): 13-19.
BERTOLINI L. Nodes and places: complexities of railway station redevelopment[J]. European Planning Studies, 1996, 4(3): 331-345.
BERTOLINI L. Spatial development patterns and public transport: the application of an analytical model in the Netherlands[J]. Planning Practice &Research, 1999, 14(2): 199-210.
赫特•约斯特•皮克，卢卡•贝托里尼，汉斯•德扬，等. 透视站点地区的发展潜能：荷兰节点—场所模型的10年发展回顾[J]. 国际城市规划，2011，26（6）：63-71.
PICK H J, BERTOLINI L, YOUNG H D, et al.Gaining insight in the development potential of station areas: a decade of node-place modeling in the Netherlands[J]. Urban Planning International, 2011,26(6): 63-71.
KAMRUZZAMAN M D, BAKER D, WASHINGTONS, et al. Advance transit oriented development typology: case study in Brisbane, Australia[J]. Journal of Transport Geography, 2014, 34: 54-70.
DAVID S V. Transit-oriented development, integration of land use and transport, and pedestrian accessibility:combining node-place model with pedestrian she dratio to evaluate and classify station areas in Lisbon[J].Journal of Transport Geography, 2015, 45: 70-80.
胡晶，黄珂，王昊. 特大城市铁路客运枢纽与城市功能互动关系——基于节点—场所模型的扩展分析[J]. 城市交通，2015，13（5）：36-42.
HU Jing, HUANG Ke, WANG Hao. Interaction between railway terminals and urban functionalities in mega cities: an extended analysis based on the node-place model[J]. Urban Transportation, 2015,13(5): 36-42.
唐恩斌，张梅青. 高铁背景下城市铁路可达性与空间相互作用格局——以江西省为例[J]. 长江流域资源与环境，2018（10）：2241-2249.
TANG Enbin, ZHANG Meiqing. Urban rail accessibility and interurban spatial effects on the background of high-speed rail in Jiangxi Province[J].Resources and Environment in the Yangtze River Basin, 2018(10): 2241-2249.
陈洁，陆锋，程昌秀. 可达性度量方法及应用研究进展评述[J]. 地理科学进展，2007（5）：100-110.
CHEN Jie, LU Feng, CHENG Changxiu. A review of research progress on accessibility measurement methods and applications[J]. Advance in Accessibility Evaluation Approaches and Applications, 2007(5): 100-110.
HOLL A. Twenty years of accessibility improvements: the case of the Spanish motorway building programme[J]. Journal of Transport Geography,2007, 15(4): 286-297.
覃成林，刘万琪，贾善铭. 中国铁路交通发展对沿线城市经济增长趋同的影响[J]. 技术经济，2015，34（3）：51-57，76.
QIN Chenglin, LIU Wanqi, JIA Shanming. Impact of railway transportation development on convergence of economic growth of cities along railway[J].Technoeconomics, 2015, 34(3): 51-57, 76.
陈小君，林晓言. 京津冀地区高铁车站开发价值评估——基于节点—场所模型[J]. 技术经济，2018，37（12）：82-93.
CHEN Xiaojun, LIN Xiaoyan. Evaluation on development value of high-speed railway station in Beijing-Tianjin-Hebei region: based on node-place model[J]. Technoeconomics, 2018, 37(12): 82-93.
王缉宪. 高速铁路影响城市与区域发展的机理[J].国际城市规划，2011，26（6）：1-5.
WANG Jixian. Urban and regional impacts of high speed railways: a preamble[J]. Urban Planning International, 2011, 26(6): 1-5.
中共武汉市委，武汉市人民政府. 武汉2049远景发展战略[M]. 武汉：武汉出版社，2014：40-64.
Wuhan Municipal Committee of the Communist Party of China, Wuhan Municipal People's Government. Wuhan 2049 long-term developmentstrategy[M]. Wuhan: Wuhan Publishing House,2014: 40-64.
侯雪，张文新，吕国玮，等. 高铁综合交通枢纽对周边区域影响研究——以北京南站为例[J]. 城市发展研究，2012，19（1）：41-46.
HOU Xue, ZHANG Wenxin, LYU Guowei, et al.Study on the influence of regional development around station of HST - taking Beijing South Station as an example[J]. Urban Development Research,2012, 19(1): 41-46.
